Painting Your Apartment: Who Should Take Responsibility?

Are you considering painting your rented apartment in Brooklyn, New York? It’s a common query among renters seeking to personalize their living spaces. However, the question of who should shoulder the responsibility often arises. Let’s delve into this topic to offer clarity and guidance.

Understanding Your Rights and Responsibilities

Firstly, it’s essential to grasp your rights as a tenant in Brooklyn. The New York City Housing Maintenance Code stipulates specific responsibilities for landlords regarding apartment maintenance, including painting. According to the code, landlords are required to paint rental units every three years. This regulation aims to ensure habitable living conditions for tenants.

Landlord Obligations vs. Tenant Preferences

While the law mandates landlords to repaint every three years, tenants may have differing preferences regarding the color scheme or timing of the paint job. Some tenants may wish to repaint sooner or choose specific colors to suit their taste and décor.

Requesting Repainting: A Step-by-Step Guide

If you feel that your apartment is due for a fresh coat of paint or you want to change the color, here’s a step-by-step guide to navigate the process:

  1. Assess the Condition: Evaluate the current state of the paint in your apartment. It may be time for a repaint if it’s chipping, peeling, or significantly discolored.
  2.  Review Your Lease Agreement: Check your lease agreement for any clauses regarding painting responsibilities. While landlords are generally responsible for painting every three years, there may be specific provisions in your lease worth considering.
  3. Communicate with Your Landlord: Reach out to your landlord or property management company to discuss your request for repainting. Be polite and reasonable in your communication, outlining your reasons for the request.
  4. Document the Request: It’s advisable to document your communication with your landlord regarding the painting request. Keep records of emails, letters, or any other forms of correspondence.
  5. Negotiate if Necessary: If your landlord hesitates to repaint or disagrees with your color choice, be open to negotiation. Compromise on the timing or color to reach a mutually satisfactory solution.

DIY Painting: Is It an Option?

While some tenants may consider painting their apartments themselves, it’s essential to approach this option cautiously. DIY painting can be feasible if your landlord agrees and you have the necessary skills and resources. However, keep in mind that any alterations to the apartment must comply with your lease agreement and local regulations.

Finding a Resolution

The question of who should paint your rented apartment in Brooklyn ultimately depends on various factors, including legal obligations, tenant preferences, and landlord cooperation. By understanding your rights and responsibilities, communicating effectively with your landlord, and exploring potential solutions, you can confidently navigate the painting process.

Remember, maintaining a positive relationship with your landlord is key to resolving issues amicably. Whether you decide to request repainting or explore DIY options, approach the situation with clarity, respect, and open communication.

For further information on tenant rights and landlord responsibilities in New York City, consult resources such as the New York State Homes and Community Renewal website.


If you’re interested in learning about buying or selling in Brooklyn, download our free Buying Into Brooklyn Ebook or our Seller’s Guide. We share a ton of valuable resources to demystify the buying and selling process.

Share Page